Results of the COOMET 881/RU-a/23 pilot comparisons in the field of measuring the nutritional value of soy flour

To ensure the reliability of measurements of the content of proteins, fats, moisture and ash in food products and food raw materials, it is necessary to use reference materials similar in composition to the analyzed samples and traceable to measurement standards and / or measurement results of national metrology institutes. The equivalence of measurement results from national metrological institutes should be confirmed in key comparisons. The results of the COOMET 881/RU-a/23 pilot comparisons in the field of measurements of the nutritional value of soy flour conducted in 2024 are presented as a preparatory stage before organizing key comparisons in this field. The national metrology institutes of Russia, the Kyrgyz Republic and China took part in the comparisons. Samples of defatted and semi-defatted soy flour composition with preliminarily studied homogeneity and stability were used as samples for comparisons. The measured characteristics were mass fractions of moisture, nitrogen, protein, crude fat and ash. When carrying out measurements, the participants used measurement methods implemented on standard measurement equipment, as well as primary reference measurement procedures. When assessing the uncertainty, the participants took into account the uncertainty components caused by the following: discrepancy between the results of parallel determinations; rounding of measurement results; direct measurements of quantities included in measurement equations; fulfillment of conditions for achieving constant mass after drying, extraction and ashing; deviation of measurement conditions from optimal values. In comparisons, consistent measurement results for mass fraction of moisture, nitrogen, protein and crude fat with expanded uncertainties (at the coverage rate 2) 0.06–0.12 %, 0.034–0.060 %, 0.19–0.40 %, 0.04–0.08 % respectively were obtained. It is two to eight times higher than the accuracy of standard measurement procedures (methods). The observed discrepant measurement result of the ash mass fraction obtained by one participant in the comparisons is due to the empirical nature of the measured value. In the case of measuring the values of empirical quantities, consistency of results can be achieved by strictly establishing the conditions for performing measurements and the permissible limits of their variation. The comparison results are planned to be used in the preparation of proposals for conducting key comparisons in the field of measuring the nutritional value of soy flour.

1. Nechaev A. P., Traubenberg A. A., Kochetkova A. A., Kolpakova V. V., Vitol I. S., Kobeleva I. B. Food Chemistry. St. Petersburg, GIORD (2007). (In Russ.)

2. Beecher G. R. Evolution of food composition knowledge in the United States from its beginning. Journal of Food Composition and Analysis, 126, 105802 (2024). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jfca.2023.105802

3. Nielsen S. S. Food Analysis, 5th ed. Springer, New York (2017).

4. Md Noh M. F., Gunasegavan R. D.-N., Mustafa Khalid N., Balasubramaniam V., Mustar S., Abd Rashed A. Recent techniques in nutrient analysis for food composition database. Molecules, 25, 4567 (2020). https://doi.org/10.3390/molecules25194567

5. Wang P., Huang J., Sun J., Liu R., Jiang T., Sun G. Evaluating the nutritional properties of food: a scoping review. Nutrients, 14(11), 2352 (2022). https://doi.org/10.3390/nu14112352

6. Sergeeva A. S. Current issues in determining fat content in food products and food raw materials (review). Measurement Standards. Reference Materials, 20(1), 59-84 (2024). (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.20915/2077-1177-2024-20-1-59-84

7. Vasil’eva I. E., Shabanova E. V. Plant-matrix reference materials as a tool for ensuring the uniformity of chemical measurements in geochemistry, ecology, agriculture and pharmacology. Measurement Standards. Reference Materials, 17(2), 3347 (2021). (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.20915/2687-0886-2021-17-2-33-47

8. Studenok V. V., Kremleva O. N. Reference materials in the system of metrological assurance of quantitative analysis. Industrial laboratory. Diagnostics of materials, 85(1(II)), 130134 (2019). (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.26896/1028-6861-2019-85-1-II-130-134

9. Phillips M. M., Sharpless K. E., Wise S. A. Standard reference materials for food analysis. Analytical and Bioanalytical Chemistry, 405(13), 4325-4335 (2013). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00216-013-6890-5

10. Wise S. A., Phillips M. M. Evolution of reference materials for the determination of organic nutrients in food and dietary supplements-a critical review. Analytical and Bioanalytical Chemistry, 411(1), 97–127 (2019). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00216-018-1473-0

11. Sergeeva A. S., Golynets O. S., Voshchula N. V., Aksupova A. M., Zhen Guo, Bo Zhao, Ling Shi, Xia Zhou, Guangliang Zhao, Xiuqin Li. Results of the COOMET 880/RU-a/23 pilot comparison in the field of measuring the nutritional value of milk powder. Measurement Techniques, 67(11), 876–887 (2025). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11018-025-02409-2

12. Gorshkov V. V., Koryakov V. I., Medvedevskikh M. Y., Medvedevskikh S. V. State primary standard of unit of mass fraction and unit of mass concentration of moisture in solid substances and solid fabricated materials. Measurement Techniques, 53(4), 386–390 (2010). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11018-010-9515-9

13. Krasheninina M. P., Medvedevskikh M. Y., Medvedevskikh S. V., Sobina E. P., Neudachina L. K. An estimate of the metrological characteristics of a standard sample of the composition of dried whole milk using primary and secondary state standards. Measurement Techniques, 56(9), 1076–1082 (2013). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11018-013-0333-8

14. Sergeeva A. S., Parfenova E. G., Golynets O. S. Development of primary reference measurement procedure and reference materials for mass fraction of crude fat (oil content) in oilseeds and other products on their base. Measurement Standards. Reference Materials, 16(3), 37–51 (2020). (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.20915/2687-0886-2020-16-3-37-51

15. Medvedevskikh M. Yu., Sergeeva A. S., Krasheninina M. P., Shokhina O. S. State primary reference procedure for the measurement of ash mass fraction in food, foodstuff and alimentary raw materials. Industrial laboratory. Diagnostics of materials, 85(6), 70–80 (2019). (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.26896/1028-6861-2019-85-6-70-80

16. Medvedevskikh S. V., Medvedevskikh M. Y., Karpov Y. A. General approaches to the estimation of uncertainty in the results of reproducing units of water content in solids and materials. Measurement Techniques, 58(8), 926–933 (2015). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11018-015-0819-7